Privacy decision compass

How long an address should live depends on the relationship

First ask whether you'll ever need to recover the account, then how long the other side will still contact you. The shortest lifespan isn't always the safest — losing an important account is a risk too.

S

Just one email

Low-value downloads, forum previews and single verifications suit a temporary inbox. No replies needed afterwards, no password recovery involved.

Generate a temporary address →
M

Notifications keep coming

Subscriptions, shopping updates and project contacts fit a forwarding alias. Your real mailbox stays hidden, and you can pause the relationship anytime.

Open the forwarding dashboard →
L

Identity and asset accounts

Banks, healthcare, government and primary work accounts must use a mailbox you control long-term with recovery and multi-factor auth — never a temporary address.

Scenario risk matrix

ScenarioRecovery neededOngoing mailSuggested address
One-off downloadLowNoTemporary inbox
Store ordersMediumYesPrivacy forwarding
Banking & governmentHighYesLong-term primary mailbox

Scenario lookup

Find your exact situation first

Unsure which address a sign-up deserves? Match the scenario below, then check whether the reasoning fits your case.

Verification codes & activation links

Forums, tools and event pages want an activated email—after that one message, the relationship is over. Use the temp inbox and stay out of their database.

Verify & discard

Shop orders & shipping updates

Mail keeps coming for weeks and returns run over email. Use a forwarding alias: long-term delivery, one-click pause when the ads start.

Newsletters & content updates

Not sure you’ll keep reading? Subscribe through an alias; keep it if it earns its place, pause it if it turns into ad spray.

Job applications & collaborations

People must reach you for months and your reputation is attached. Use your long-term primary mailbox with two-factor auth enabled.

Banking, government & healthcare

Account recovery and legal notices ride on this address; any temporary scheme is a liability. Only a mailbox you fully control.

Three questions

Three questions pick the right tier

No scenario list to memorise—run these three questions before any sign-up and the answer points at the right address.

  1. Will this account ever need recovery?

    Anything with password resets or identity checks rules out temp addresses. A recovery email sent to a destroyed inbox is a lost account.

  2. How long will they keep writing?

    Meaningful mail beyond 24 hours (bills, notices, replies) needs at least an alias; a single expected email is cleanest on a temp address.

  3. What does exposing your real address cost?

    Unknown reputation or list-selling risk? Even long-term relationships deserve an alias: rotate the alias when abused, never your mailbox.

Address tiers

Three tiers, each owning its relationships

Privacy email isn’t about hiding—it’s about placing every relationship in the right tier so one breach never cascades.

01

Tier 1 · Long-term primary

Banks, government, employers and core platforms only. Two-factor on, never typed into unknown forms.

02

Tier 2 · Forwarding aliases

Shops, subscriptions and communities. Your real address stays hidden; one alias per relationship—pause it, and know exactly who leaked you.

03

Tier 3 · Temporary inbox

One-off verifications and trials. Three-hour lifetime, 24-hour cap, then address and mail are destroyed together.

Decision FAQ

Privacy Compass FAQ

Can one alias serve several sites?

It can, but shouldn’t. One alias per site means you can tell exactly who sold or leaked your address—and pause only the affected relationship.

Will sites detect my temp address?

Some maintain disposable-domain blocklists and refuse sign-up. Don’t cycle temp addresses against a hard block; forwarding aliases ride an independent domain that typically isn’t listed.

Can I swap an alias for my real email later?

Most sites let you change the bound email in settings. “Alias first, upgrade later” is the safe default; the reverse—unexposing a real address—is impossible.

Isn’t a three-tier system overkill?

Day to day it’s one rule: never give unknown forms your primary address. TMP10 generates the aliases and temp inboxes, so there’s nothing to memorise.

TMP10 Product Advice · Put it to work

Start at the tier the compass points to

Short relationships go to the temporary inbox—ready instantly. Anything longer starts with a Privacy Forwarding alias so your real mailbox never surfaces. Both tools are free, nothing to install.